Menu of Roadhouse Carlsville in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, USA

Menu Overview

Roadhouse Carlsville, nestled at 5790 WI-42 in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, stands as a robust local bar & grill with a down-to-earth charm that invites both regulars and visitors alike. Known for its hearty American fare and a welcoming atmosphere, this spot is a go-to for anyone seeking comfort food with a laid-back vibe.

The menu here highlights some true crowd-pleasers, notably the Cheeseburger and Fries, a staple that locals rave about for its juicy, thick patties and perfectly seasoned fries. Both Kyle McCann and L B praised the burgers as juicy and flavorful, making them a reliable choice for burger enthusiasts. The fries, often described as "some of the best ever," have a crispness that complements the burger perfectly, creating a classic Bar & Grill duo that satisfies every time.

Another standout is the Deluxe Burger Cheese Curds, offering a local Wisconsin twist—a generous helping of cheese curds that balance richness with a satisfying crisp. Rebecca Monticello’s mention of the curds alongside her perch sandwich and coleslaw highlights the portion size and quality of these offerings, signaling a well-rounded meal experience. For something unique, the ghost pepper cheese bombs, described by Kyle as grilled cheese cubes with a punch, add an adventurous kick and are a must-try for spice lovers.

The Chicken Dumpling Soup is indicative of the comfort-oriented menu, delivering warmth and hominess in every spoonful. Meanwhile, the availability of traditional Bar & Grill staples—like Broasted Chicken, CharBroiled Chicken Breast Sandwich, and Chicken Tender Basket—showcases a menu designed for wide appeal, catering both to those who favor fried classics and grilled options.

When it comes to beverages, Roadhouse Carlsville offers a solid lineup of domestic beers such as Budweiser, Pabst Blue Ribbon, Bud Light, and Miller 64, along with local favorites like Lakefront. The inclusion of seltzers and hard coffee (White Claw and Pabst Blue Ribbon Hard Coffee) adds a modern edge to the drink selection. Wine drinkers will find an option in Pinot Grigio, rounding out the beverage offering to accommodate different palates. Customers like Nancy Bast note the clean environment and perfect drinks, which complement the casual ambiance.

The setting complements the menu well—a large shaded porch with ceiling fans keeps the atmosphere comfortable even during humid Wisconsin summers, and amenities like a pool table enhance the social, welcoming feel mentioned by patron L B. While some have found the food “alright” or “nothing special,” most reviews reflect a solid, enjoyable local experience, where freshness and friendly service create a reliable dining outing.

In summary, Roadhouse Carlsville’s menu shines brightest with its juicy cheeseburgers, signature cheese curds, and comforting soup, backed by a sturdy drinks menu tailored for the bar & grill crowd. The mix of classic Wisconsin bar food and engaging flavors makes this spot a worthy stop to experience authentic local fare in Sturgeon Bay.